Should we allow discrimination?

Today’s Link

Here is a timely and somewhat controversial issue for everyone to chew over.  The attached link refers to a case in England where a couple refused to allow a same-sex couple to share a room together in their hotel, citing that they didn’t allow unmarried couples/same-sex partners to sleep together in their hotel.  The appeals court in the UK today upheld the ruling that this was discriminatory action and that “when offering a service, people cannot use their beliefs – religious or otherwise – to discriminate against others”.

This is timely because we are seeing the same issues surfacing once more in the USA where Catholic hospitals and organisations are furious about the fact that they have to provide health plans to their employees that provide birth control.  Note that the law doesn’t make people use it, just that it has to be available.  Why?  Because some people who work for an organization may not be Catholic and may want to use it.  You can’t discriminate in employment by law with regard to religion (hiring/firing) as I understand it, so why should the employer be allowed to discriminate through the back door once the people are working?

It is a tough one in some ways.  I understand that people may hold strong religious views, but discriminating against someone is still wrong.  No one is saying you can’t have your beliefs.  You just can’t use them to inflict damage or harm on someone else.  That seems reasonable, right?  But it seems that where religion is involved, organisation and people want to have it both ways.  Would I be allowed to refuse a Catholic service in my business?  You can just imagine the shit storm that would stir up…..  The bible has a dubious record on race too, so should religious organisations be able to discriminate on race too?  These are serious questions, though in my mind they are easy to solve.  Discrimination is wrong.  If you don’t want to have to offer a service to everyone, then you can choose not to offer the service to anyone; you can’t slice and dice it to suit your beliefs!

Now why is this so hard?

Big love,



One thought on “Should we allow discrimination?

  1. Wow, I mean wow, I have been reading every single one of your posts, but haven’t really felt the urge to comment… But this one is not a tough one at all. So let’s look at this from any other angle: would we be outraged if this hotel didn’t allow children to stay or black people or Chinese, or women with glasses like me… or unmarried hetero-sexual couples, I needn’t say more…
    Excuse my harsh words, but if someone doesn’t want 2 men or women sharing a bedroom at their own house because they feel that that would make the house unholy or whatever, it’s up to them, surely they won’t invite their (probably non-existent) gay friends over, but if you operate a hotel or a hospital it becomes a completely different issue… At least the holy men with their purifying ceremonies will not run out of business, eh…SERIOUSLY

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s